Australian cloud for business software — built and run in Sydney since 2002

NetLeverage
NetLeverage

Google Groups does not accept, or holds, mail from outside the organisation

Technical article
Troubleshooting

About this article: This article is reviewed against the cited sources. This is source research, not lab validation. Check the stated versions and your own requirements before making changes.

When someone outside your Google Workspace organisation emails a group and the message never arrives, or it waits for approval, the group is following its posting settings. Three different controls do this. The organisation policy can stop owners from accepting outside mail. Who can post can exclude external people on one group. Message moderation can hold mail from non-members even when posting is allowed. Google's pages describe these settings and give no bounce text, so a sender's error message cannot be matched to one of them here. The organisation-wide option and the settings of a group you already have are separate: the fixes below change them one at a time.

What the symptom means

Google's sharing page says that, by default, group owners "Can't allow emails from external users". The default is "Unchecked (not allowed)". While both external options stay unchecked, "group owners can't allow external group members or emails." An administrator can still allow outside members or messages for one group in the Admin console or with the Groups Settings API. Selecting the allow options "Doesn't change the default group-level settings".

Who can post is separate. In the Admin console, "The External category includes anyone outside your organization. External people can be group members or non-members." Who can post "Specifies who can publish messages to the group."

Moderation is set in Google Groups. The Learning Center's three choices are: "No moderation—Post messages as they are received without reviewing them." "Moderate messages from non-members—Review and approve messages from non-members before sending them to the group." "Moderate all messages—Review and approve all messages before sending them to the group." A non-member is held under the second or third choice.

Membership is not the same as posting. When the organisation-wide group access setting is private and owners may add external members but may not allow incoming email from outside, "only organization members can post messages to the group." If owners may allow incoming outside email but not external members, "both organization and external users can post messages to the group. External users can post by email only and can't view messages from the group."

Likely causes

Cause What you see How to confirm
Incoming outside email is unchecked Owners cannot turn on outside posting Sharing settings for Groups for Business
The group's own settings were not changed The policy allows outside mail, and this group still does not take it The group's Access settings, not the sharing page
Who can post omits External Staff mail arrives; outside mail does not The group's Access settings
Non-member or all-message moderation The message waits, or a moderator sees it pending Posting policies, Message moderation

Prove the cause before changing anything

All of these are read-only. Write the values down. That note is what you put back.

1. Organisation policy. Admin console, Menu, Apps, Google Workspace, Groups for Business, Sharing settings. You need the Groups for Business administrator privilege. Record whether "Group owners can allow incoming email from outside the organization" is checked, and whether external members are allowed.

2. This group. Menu, Directory, Groups, the group, Access settings. Record the access type (Public, Team, Announcement only, Restricted, or Custom), who can post, and whether external members are allowed. Customising any option changes the type to Custom.

3. Moderation. In Google Groups, open the group, Group settings, Posting policies. Record Message moderation and whether Allow Email Posting is checked. Clearing that box means "people can't send messages to the group using the group's email address."

4. The sender. A member follows Who can post. A non-member also follows "Moderate messages from non-members".

Fix

Let this group accept outside mail

To save the current settings first, copy this group's access type, Who can post and external-members values from its Access settings page into a text file named group-access-before.txt.

Risk: the next steps change this group's access settings, so people outside your organisation can send mail to its address.

Open the group, Access settings, Edit. Include External under Who can post if non-members should publish. Turn on external members only if they should be members. Click Save.

To undo it: put the access type, Who can post and external-members values from group-access-before.txt back, then save.

Turn on the organisation-wide option, only if it is off

The organisation checkbox is a different change from the group change in the first subsection, which has its own warning and undo. Google's sharing page says: "Changing these settings does not affect any existing external group member or message." Make the group change there first; the checkbox alone does not repair this group.

To save the current settings first, write the state of both Groups for Business sharing checkboxes into a text file named group-sharing-before.txt.

Risk: the next step changes the organisation-wide sharing setting for Groups for Business. If multi-party approval is on, "any change to sharing settings triggers a Multi-party approval process" and the change waits for that process.

In Sharing settings, turn on incoming email from outside the organisation, then save.

To undo it: set the checkboxes back to the state in group-sharing-before.txt, then save.

Hold outside mail instead of rejecting it

To save the current setting first, write the value of Message moderation and the Allow Email Posting box into a text file named group-moderation-before.txt.

Risk: the next step changes message moderation for this group. "Moderate all messages" also holds staff mail.

In Posting policies, leave Allow Email Posting checked. Set Message moderation to "Moderate messages from non-members" or "Moderate all messages". Click Save changes.

To undo it: set Message moderation to the value in group-moderation-before.txt. Google's Learning Center lists the unmoderated choice as "No moderation".

Example (illustrative): support@example.com rejects a customer. Incoming outside email is unchecked, and Who can post has no External tick. The administrator records both, ticks External for that group, and sets "Moderate messages from non-members". The next customer message waits. Staff mail still posts. Other existing groups stay as they were.

Confirm the fix

  1. From an outside address that is not a member, send a new message. Do not reuse one that was already rejected.
  2. With non-member moderation, someone who has "Who can moderate content" sees it waiting. Google says it is not sent to the group until it is reviewed and approved.
  3. A staff message still follows the staff rule.
  4. A group you did not edit is unchanged.

What to watch afterwards

  • A moderator queue with nobody watching it looks like a broken group.
  • Who can view conversations is separate. Posting by email does not grant the archive.

Risks and limits

  • Google's pages describe settings. They do not give the bounce text a sender's mail program shows.
  • Groups for Business must be on. The Learning Center says to ask an administrator when Google Groups is missing.

Sources